What Happens to Your Insurance After an OWI
You received an OWI conviction in Indiana. Your license is suspended. You've been told you need SR-22 proof of financial responsibility to reinstate. The question you're asking right now: how much will your insurance go up, and will your current carrier even keep you?
Most Indiana drivers in your position discover the hard truth at renewal: their standard carrier cancels the policy outright after the conviction appears on their motor vehicle record. The rate increase isn't an add-on to your old premium — it's an entirely new rate structure with a non-standard carrier who writes post-OWI policies. That shift typically doubles or triples what you paid before the suspension.
Compare car insurance rates in your state
Get quotes from licensed carriers — no obligation, no spam, results in minutes.
Get Your Free QuoteIndiana OWI Premium Increase
70–150%
Post-OWI drivers in Indiana see average rate increases between 70% and 150% compared to pre-conviction premiums, with the highest increases among drivers under 25 or those with prior violations. Rates remain elevated for 3–5 years depending on carrier underwriting.
Indiana Department of Insurance market conduct data
Why Standard Carriers Cancel After OWI Conviction
Indiana law requires continuous liability insurance for all registered vehicles under IC 9-25-4, and SR-22 proof of financial responsibility for OWI convictions under IC 9-25. Your current carrier knows you need SR-22. Most won't provide it.
Standard-tier carriers — State Farm, Allstate, Erie, Nationwide — underwrite drivers with clean or near-clean records. An OWI conviction moves you out of their risk tier. They cancel at renewal rather than issue SR-22 because their underwriting guidelines exclude post-OWI drivers entirely. The cancellation notice arrives 30–60 days after your conviction posts to the Indiana Bureau of Motor Vehicles record.
You're now shopping for coverage in the non-standard market: carriers who specialize in high-risk drivers. These carriers assume higher claim risk and price accordingly. The 70–150% increase reflects not just your OWI, but the structural reality that you're now insured by a different class of carrier with different pricing models.
The blocker: you cannot reinstate your Indiana license without SR-22 on file with the BMV, and most standard carriers will not file SR-22 for post-OWI drivers.
Carriers Writing Post-OWI Policies in Indiana
Progressive, Geico, and The General write SR-22 policies for Indiana OWI drivers statewide. Progressive typically offers the lowest rates for first-time OWI offenders with otherwise clean records; Geico competes closely in suburban counties; The General specializes in drivers with multiple violations or lapsed coverage. All three provide online quotes and same-day SR-22 electronic filing to the BMV.
Dairyland and GAINSCO write non-standard coverage including non-owner SR-22 policies for drivers who sold their vehicle during suspension or never owned one. Non-owner policies cost $40–$80/month and satisfy Indiana's SR-22 requirement without insuring a specific vehicle. Bristol West and National General also write Indiana OWI policies but typically require broker contact rather than direct online quotes.
Related Articles
How Long Rates Stay Elevated After OWI
Indiana requires SR-22 filing for 3 years after OWI conviction, measured from the conviction date, not the filing date. The BMV monitors continuous SR-22 coverage electronically through the INSPECT system. Any lapse triggers automatic re-suspension.
Your insurance rate stays elevated for the entire 3-year SR-22 period and typically 2–3 years beyond. Carriers re-rate your policy at each renewal based on your current motor vehicle record. The OWI conviction remains visible on your Indiana driving record for 5 years. Most carriers reduce your rate gradually starting in year 4 if no additional violations occur.
Drivers who complete the OWI substance abuse program and maintain continuous coverage without claims see the steepest rate reductions between year 3 and year 5. Expect to pay 30–50% above pre-OWI rates even after SR-22 filing ends. Clean driving for 5 full years resets you to standard-tier eligibility with most carriers.
Indiana OWI Reinstatement Fee
$250
Indiana charges a $250 base reinstatement fee for first-time OWI suspensions. Second and subsequent OWI offenses carry a $500 reinstatement fee. Both require SR-22 proof of insurance on file before the BMV processes reinstatement.
Indiana Code 9-29-8
SR-22 Filing Process and Timeline
You purchase a liability policy from a carrier writing SR-22 in Indiana. The carrier files the SR-22 certificate electronically with the Indiana BMV within 24 hours. The BMV receives the filing and updates your record, but reinstatement is not automatic — you still need to pay the $250 reinstatement fee, complete any court-ordered substance abuse program, and serve the mandatory suspension period.
Indiana OWI suspensions carry a minimum hard suspension before reinstatement eligibility. For first-time OWI with BAC under 0.15, the suspension is typically 180 days with potential eligibility for Specialized Driving Privileges after 30 days. For BAC 0.15 or higher, or for second offenses, the hard suspension extends and ignition interlock installation is required for any driving privileges. SR-22 must be on file before you can apply for either full reinstatement or Specialized Driving Privileges through the court.
Compare Carriers Before Committing
Rate spreads among non-standard carriers writing Indiana OWI policies often exceed $100/month for identical coverage. The General may quote $210/month for state-minimum liability in Marion County while Progressive quotes $140 for the same driver and coverage. County matters: Lake County and Allen County drivers pay 15–25% more than drivers in Hamilton or Hendricks counties due to claim frequency.
Get quotes from at least three carriers writing SR-22 in your county. Provide accurate conviction details — BAC level, conviction date, prior violations — because underwriters price each factor separately. Lowballing your BAC or omitting prior tickets produces an artificially low quote that the carrier revises upward or cancels after pulling your motor vehicle record. Quote with your actual record. The price you see at binding is the price you pay.